Sign up to stay up to date on the Garden City Elementary School, FL Real Estate Market!

or Create your own market report
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
12771 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,373 $276,940 $201 4 days
12773 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,373 $276,940 $201 4 days
3324 Penny Cove Lane 3 3 1,725 $206,000 $119 5 days
12718 Cacao Tree Trail 3 2 1,618 $320,000 $197 6 days
12573 Lake Taylor Lane 5 3 2,574 $360,000 $139 9 days
12759 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,492 $285,940 $191 11 days
12761 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,492 $285,940 $191 11 days
12926 Rubber Fig Terrace 4 2 1,856 $358,208 $193 12 days
11708 Lem Turner Road 3 2 2,322 $800,000 $344 23 days
2408 Sea Palm Avenue 3 2 1,711 $320,000 $187 24 days
4143 Sitka Pine Circle 4 2 1,774 $362,350 $204 32 days
4131 Sitka Pine Circle 5 3 2,030 $392,395 $193 32 days
4017 Sitka Pine Circle 4 2 1,774 $368,395 $207 32 days
4101 Sitka Pine Circle 4 3 2,160 $385,395 $178 32 days
4137 Sitka Pine Circle 4 2 1,609 $338,350 $210 32 days
11779 Alexandra Drive 3 2 1,650 $280,769 $170 34 days
12089 Yew Tree Road 5 3 2,499 $417,350 $167 46 days
12047 Yew Tree Road 3 2 1,618 $352,350 $217 46 days
11532 Tori Lane 4 2 2,168 $285,000 $131 50 days
3652 Lydia Estates Terrace 3 2 2,109 $325,000 $154 55 days
12137 Yew Tree Road 4 2 1,774 $362,350 $204 61 days
12125 Yew Tree Road 5 3 2,030 $387,350 $190 61 days
12113 Yew Tree Road 5 3 2,499 $409,350 $163 68 days
12101 Yew Tree Road 4 2 1,774 $355,395 $200 68 days
11603 West Court Boulevard 5 9 4,788 $839,990 $175 44 days
11592 Pleasant Creek Drive 3 2 1,356 $279,000 $205 72 days
12053 Yew Tree Road 4 2 1,774 $359,850 $202 75 days
12041 Yew Tree Road 4 2 1,774 $359,850 $202 75 days
12023 Yew Tree Road 4 3 2,160 $382,350 $177 75 days
12017 Yew Tree Road 4 2 1,774 $359,850 $202 82 days
12131 Yew Tree Road 3 2 1,646 $332,395 $201 82 days
12035 Yew Tree Road 4 2 1,609 $339,395 $210 89 days
11820 Poydras Lane 3 2 1,860 $275,000 $147 93 days
4011 Sitka Pine Circle 3 2 1,618 $339,175 $209 5 days
4276 Quaking Street 3 2 1,618 $299,000 $184 132 days
11595 Dunns Crossing Drive 4 3 2,565 $363,360 $141 150 days
12558 Lake Madison Lane 4 3 2,574 $367,000 $142 163 days
3072 Bessent Road 2 1 896 $148,900 $166 167 days
4131 Caper Tree Way 3 2 1,646 $269,905 $163 37 days
11451 W Court Boulevard N/A N/A N/A $79,900 Unknown 90 days
8223 Helmsley Boulevard 3 2 1,512 $275,000 $181 24 days
3780 Juliet Leia Circle W 4 2 2,030 $310,000 $152 309 days
12601 Lake Madison Lane 4 3 2,114 $379,000 $179 416 days
Average: 3.7 2.5 1,912 $345,829 $186 68 days
Viewing 1 - 43 of 43
Viewing 1 - 43 of 43
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Cost per ft2 DOM
4526 Clam Shell Drive 4 2 1,617 $285,000 $176 5 days
10725 Meadowlea Drive 3 2 1,284 $115,000 $89 14 days
4125 Sitka Pine Circle 4 2 1,609 $342,350 $212 19 days
4113 Sitka Pine Circle 5 3 2,363 $395,350 $167 12 days
12517 Russian Olive Road 4 2 1,862 $359,900 $193 11 days
4167 Sitka Pine Circle 5 3 2,030 $391,395 $192 45 days
12778 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,492 $279,940 $187 55 days
12776 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,492 $279,940 $187 53 days
12774 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,492 $285,940 $191 44 days
12772 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,492 $279,940 $187 69 days
2959 Frances Avenue 2 2 960 $134,900 $140 79 days
12119 Yew Tree Road 3 2 1,646 $333,395 $202 75 days
12046 Yew Tree Road 4 2 1,774 $360,395 $203 32 days
4161 Sitka Pine Circle 4 2 1,774 $354,350 $199 61 days
4154 Sitka Pine Circle 4 2 1,609 $338,350 $210 44 days
12071 Yew Tree Road 3 2 1,646 $333,395 $202 45 days
12143 Yew Tree Road 4 3 2,160 $377,350 $174 75 days
12082 Yew Tree Road 3 2 1,618 $334,350 $206 20 days
12710 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,492 $300,175 $201 67 days
12708 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,492 $300,175 $201 67 days
12118 Yew Tree Road 3 2 1,618 $337,350 $208 81 days
12107 Yew Tree Road 4 3 2,160 $372,350 $172 94 days
12767 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,492 $300,175 $201 80 days
12769 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,492 $300,175 $201 80 days
3787 Juliet Leia Circle W 4 2 2,030 $339,000 $166 132 days
11967 Chester Creek Road 4 3 2,761 $375,000 $135 137 days
12770 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,492 $300,175 $201 102 days
12768 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,492 $269,940 $180 98 days
12764 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,504 $264,990 $176 1 day
2897 Post Street N/A N/A N/A $199,900 Unknown 191 days
6894 Barney Road 3 2 1,813 $294,888 $162 219 days
V C Johnson Rd Road N/A N/A N/A $215,000 Unknown 293 days
Average: 3.4 2.5 1,691 $304,704 $184 51 days
Viewing 1 - 32 of 32
Viewing 1 - 32 of 32
Address Beds Baths Living ft2 List Price Sold Price Cost per ft2 Sold Date
12083 Yew Tree Road 4 3 2,160 $362,350 $357,350 $165 9/24/26
12034 Yew Tree Road 4 2 1,774 $355,990 $355,990 $200 9/23/26
12052 Yew Tree Road 5 3 2,499 $415,350 $415,350 $166 9/23/26
12064 Yew Tree Road 5 3 2,499 $409,350 $409,350 $163 9/23/26
12058 Yew Tree Road 4 3 2,160 $359,350 $359,350 $166 9/23/26
12511 Russian Olive Road 4 2 1,609 $327,950 $327,950 $203 9/18/26
5114 Angel Lake Drive 3 2 1,811 $340,000 $340,000 $187 9/14/26
12011 Yew Tree Road 4 3 2,273 $427,030 $420,000 $184 9/11/26
12455 Russian Olive Road 4 2 1,862 $359,810 $350,000 $187 9/11/26
12196 Yew Tree Road 4 3 2,160 $357,350 $349,900 $161 9/11/26
10721 Meadowlea Drive 3 2 1,272 $249,900 $240,000 $188 8/31/26
12763 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,373 $269,940 $255,990 $186 8/31/26
12463 Russian Olive Road 5 2 1,657 $346,990 $331,500 $200 8/31/26
12197 Yew Tree Road 3 2 1,646 $319,350 $319,350 $194 8/31/26
12142 Yew Tree Road 4 2 1,774 $364,350 $364,350 $205 8/27/26
4005 Sitka Pine Circle 4 2 1,774 $354,350 $350,000 $197 8/26/26
12124 Yew Tree Road 5 3 2,363 $394,350 $394,350 $166 8/25/26
12765 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,373 $276,940 $255,990 $186 8/25/26
4240 Key Vega Court 3 2 1,104 $201,000 $200,000 $181 8/21/26
12209 Yew Tree Road 5 3 2,363 $359,350 $359,350 $152 8/21/26
12766 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,504 $285,940 $259,940 $172 8/18/26
12154 Yew Tree Road 5 3 2,363 $369,395 $369,395 $156 8/18/26
12095 Yew Tree Road 5 3 2,363 $379,850 $379,850 $160 8/14/26
12059 Yew Tree Road 3 2 1,646 $332,350 $332,350 $201 8/13/26
12130 Yew Tree Road 5 3 2,499 $422,350 $422,350 $169 8/4/26
12760 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,373 $264,940 $249,940 $182 7/31/26
12762 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,373 $264,940 $249,940 $182 7/30/26
12257 Yew Tree Road 3 2 1,459 $299,350 $299,350 $205 7/30/26
12456 Russian Olive Road 3 2 1,714 $339,900 $339,900 $198 7/24/26
12136 Yew Tree Road 3 2 1,646 $337,350 $337,350 $204 7/23/26
11862 Alexandra Drive 3 2 1,293 $247,000 $236,000 $182 7/22/26
4142 Caper Tree Way 3 2 1,714 $339,350 $339,350 $197 7/17/26
12166 Yew Tree Road 5 3 2,030 $374,350 $359,310 $177 7/14/26
12239 Yew Tree Road 5 3 2,499 $407,440 $405,000 $162 7/9/26
12190 Yew Tree Road 4 2 1,489 $326,940 $326,940 $219 6/30/26
11341 V C Johnson Road 3 3 2,629 $724,000 $724,000 $275 6/29/26
12745 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,504 $285,940 $282,000 $187 6/29/26
12743 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,504 $285,940 $285,000 $189 6/26/26
4143 Caper Tree Way 3 2 1,287 $316,940 $316,940 $246 6/25/26
12780 Cacao Tree Trail 4 2 1,488 $295,000 $295,000 $198 6/24/26
12747 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,373 $276,940 $275,000 $200 6/23/26
12753 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,504 $285,940 $285,940 $190 6/23/26
12749 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,373 $276,940 $276,940 $201 6/22/26
12751 Geronimo Place 3 3 1,504 $285,940 $285,940 $190 6/22/26
12462 Russian Olive Road 4 2 1,609 $328,900 $324,490 $201 6/19/26
12214 Yew Tree Road 3 2 1,459 $318,940 $308,940 $211 6/18/26
12148 Yew Tree Road 5 3 2,499 $414,350 $414,350 $165 6/18/26
4130 Caper Tree Way 4 2 1,609 $325,395 $325,395 $202 6/17/26
12178 Yew Tree Road 5 3 2,499 $411,850 $407,500 $163 6/16/26
3699 Juliet Leia Circle S 4 2 1,978 $350,000 $340,000 $171 6/12/26
Average: 3.7 2.5 1,813 $331,608 $327,469 $182
Viewing 1 - 50 of 113
Viewing 1 - 50 of 113
© 2026 Northeast Florida Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved. This data is up-to-date as of . For the most current information, contact Military Realty Florida.