Anastasia Hills Homes for Sale

Anastasia Hills is a residential subdivision in St. Augustine, on Anastasia Island, the barrier island facing the Atlantic across the Matanzas River from the historic downtown. Unlike the condominium rows along the beach, Anastasia Hills is an inland island neighborhood, with houses on wooded residential streets under the island's oak canopy. The setting is defined by the island's geography: the ocean and Anastasia State Park on one side, the river and the old city on the other, and St. Augustine Beach just down the island. Residents cross the Bridge of Lions for downtown and use the island's own shops and restaurants day to day. Homes here sit within that established island fabric, close to the lighthouse and the beach access points. Browse current Anastasia Hills homes for sale below.

Newest Anastasia Hills Homes for Sale

5485 Atlantic, St. Augustine $950,000 ▼

OWNER FINANCING AVAILABLE TO QUALIFIED PARTIES. Rare Butler Beach prime redevelopment opportunity on sought-after Atlantic View. This 50'x150' (0.14 acre) ocean-side ...

• 68 DOM

5306 Pelican Way, St. Augustine $995,000

The beach lifestyle you've been dreaming of starts here. Build your custom coastal retreat on this newly available oversized homesite with potential ocean views in the de...

• 174 DOM