Creighton Forest Homes for Sale

Creighton Forest is an established neighborhood in Fleming Island in Clay County, set back from the St. Johns River and Doctors Lake on the western side of the Fleming Island peninsula. Mature oaks and tall pines shade its streets, and the surrounding area mixes older custom homes with the planned communities that grew up along the main Fleming Island corridors. Homes here are single-family residences, and the home currently listed is priced at $899,000. It dates to around 1980 and offers about 2,675 square feet, a footprint typical of the larger, wooded homesites found along streets such as Fishermans. Daily shopping, dining and medical services cluster nearby within Fleming Island, and Orange Park lies just to the north. Public schools are part of Clay County District Schools, and Paterson is among the schools serving the area. Browse the current Creighton Forest homes for sale below.

Newest Creighton Forest Homes for Sale

3203 Us Highway 17, Fleming Island image
3203 Us Highway 17, Fleming Island $795,000

WATERFRONT ACREAGE WITH RIVER ACCESS--BUILD YOUR DREAM HOME! Rare opportunity to own approximately an acre of beautiful waterfront property in Orange Park and create the ...

  • 40 DOM
901 - B Creighton Road, Fleming Island image
901 - B Creighton Road, Fleming Island $1,200,000

Come build your DREAM HOME on one of the FEW desirable waterfront lots in Fleming Island! This lot is situated down the private, sought-after Creighton Rd located just ov...

  • 45 DOM
901 - A Creighton Road, Fleming Island image
901 - A Creighton Road, Fleming Island $1,200,000

Come build your DREAM HOME on one of the FEW desirable waterfront lots in Fleming Island! This lot is situated down the private, sought-after Creighton Rd located just ov...

  • 45 DOM
1105 Fishermans Way, Fleming Island image
1105 Fishermans Way, Fleming Island $899,000

Boater's Paradise! This beautifully remodeled one story brick waterfront home has Doctors Lake/ St. Johns River frontage as well as canal frontage. Located near the Docto...

  • 3 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 2,675 SqFt.
  • 49 DOM
901 Creighton Road, Fleming Island image
901 Creighton Road, Fleming Island $2,400,000

SELLER HAS ALSO SPLIT THE LOTS DOWN THE MIDDLE AND IS WILLING TO SELL THEM SEPARATELY (ALSO LISTED INDIVIDUALLY). Come build your DREAM HOME on one of the FEW desirable w...

  • 53 DOM
© 2026 Northeast Florida Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved. This data is up-to-date as of . For the most current information, contact Military Realty Florida.

Address Search