Keystone Heights Clay County Homes for Sale

Keystone Heights is a small city in southwestern Clay County, in Florida's lake region, strung along State Road 21 between Melrose and the Bradford County line and surrounded by the chain of lakes that includes Lake Brooklyn, Lake Geneva and Santa Fe Lake. It is a quiet, rural-leaning community, and its housing mixes conventional single-family homes with manufactured and mobile homes on generous lots under the pines. Current listings run from $118,000 to $495,000, with a median around $274,900, a median of about 1,666 square feet and a median build year around 2017 across older and newer stock alike. Public schools are part of Clay County District Schools, including Keystone Heights and McRae elementary schools. Gainesville lies to the southwest and Orange Park to the northeast along SR 21. Browse current Keystone Heights homes for sale below.

Newest Keystone Heights Clay County Homes for Sale

© 2026 Northeast Florida Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved. This data is up-to-date as of . For the most current information, contact Military Realty Florida.